who killed the lobbyist in boneswho killed the lobbyist in bones

who killed the lobbyist in bones who killed the lobbyist in bones

3. The Apprentice, the Gormogon's apprentice before Zack. Did Gordon Gordon really make a dont get up joke to Hodgins? But thanks to Dr. Making him, as he has put it since the beginning of the shows run, King of the Lab.. Yes, James Immekus is credited as Gormogon's Apprentice. Dustins mother thinks he was an upstanding manager at the local Waffle Shack, but he lost that job six months ago and never told her. 2022 - 2023 Times Mojo - All Rights Reserved What is the best fanfiction ever written. And I want to know whats going to happen to Dustins mom. Why was Jonathan Adams replaced on Bones? Foxs Bones has formally decided to write star Emily Deschanels real-life pregnancy into the series storyline, TVLine has learned. vw golf door lock problems. Booth and Brennan go to the nursing home with a warrant to obtain dental imprints from Graves, who is suffering from Alzheimer's disease. The Knight on the Grid is the eighth episode of the third season of Bones. Bones thought to belong to soldiers killed at the Battle of Waterloo have been discovered in an attic in Belgium. Nicolette Davis, a commissioned officer in the Army, has accused Rep. Tom Reed (R-N.Y.) of sexual misconduct. yea, Zack killed the lobby guy, in extended version of the episode he confesses to the murder, but they give him psych care because he helped them get the master. Your email address will not be published. The current active Gormogon, killed by Booth, did not kill the. As it turned out, the changes were due to a long-awaited pregnancy of the actress. Alphaslasted just two seasons, but it still gave Cartwright a chance to hone his craft opposite an impressive cast which included David Strathairn, Malik Yoba, Sean Astin, Summer Glau, Brent Spiner, and two-time Oscar winner Mahershala Ali. Because, at the end of the day, he did not kill [the lobbyist in Season 3]. 2023 Oscars predictions: See who will win at the 95th Academy Awards. What number do u call to see if your phone is tapped? After revealing the location of Gormogon to Booth and Brennan, Zack Addy confesses to "killing" him and is sent to McKinley Psychiatric Hospital in exchange for full co-operation with Caroline Julian. Bones Casts Ignacio Serricchio as New Intern Season 9 | TVLine. From Austin Butler and Cate Blanchett to a potential Best Supporting Actress toss-up, see who EW thinks will win at the 2023 Oscars. But Ray seems genuinely shocked to learn that Dustin is dead, and the evidence suggests there was a third accomplice; someone held Dustins arms back while Ray hit his face with a wrench. Hanson offered thoughts on Cartwright's professional predicament inthat sameTV Line interview. I guess in the basic cut of the season 4 they had to go with the basic version of ep 15 s03 where we do not see his confession of the murder of lobbyist? The next day, Dr. Sweets comes into the autopsy room where Cam is examining the body. TimesMojo is a social question-and-answer website where you can get all the answers to your questions. ", Bones star Emily Deschanel offeredTV Linea similarly praise-worthy view on Cartwright's talent and devastating series exit. In season three, a shocking twist revealed Addy was working with the season's big bad The Gormogon, and even killed someone for him, the lobbyist Ray Porter . The Gormogon is a fictional character featured in a story arc of Season 3 of the Fox drama Bones. Jack Hodgins (TJ Thyne): The bad news for those Hodgins fans who had hoped to see him regain his ability to walk: He ended the series in his wheelchair. Exclusive: employee says manager told her to stop marking cars for repair, as Ohio derailment brings hard look at industry's record of blocking safety rules He was a hero. It does look like Zack. Booth and Sweets identified him as a victim of The Gormogon. Graves hisses at Brennan when she attempts to get the imprints, revealing that he has no teeth. Is it legal in Texas to drink with your parents? With Snoop Dogg, Pam Grier, Michael T. Weiss, Clifton Powell. Shes going to take out her aggression on a bunch of cars, and shes going to like it. Sweets wanted him to tell the truth because he believes that The Apprentice is still out there, but Zack told him that "The Master" killed him in order to recruit Zack because "there could only ever be two." (season 12) The twelfth and final season of the American television series Bones premiered on January 3, 2017, on Fox and concluded on March 28, 2017. It was a creative decision to shake things up and make a good season finale. Millegan said that after clarifying that Addy was not a cannibal, he had mixed feelings about the revelation. Temperance Bones Brennan : I applaud your ambition, Dr. Wells, but being the best in your field requires more than the accumulation of hours. 4 Arizona prosecutors were also very successful lobbyistsnone of the bills that they opposed was able to pass. Booth was able to turn the table on his would-be assassins, but after being treated for the wounds he sustained in the attack, he was arrested. Here's hoping. At the courthouse, Booth informs Brennan he has decided to obtain a court order to monitor all of Graves' visitors. Hes been stealing, robbing banks, and generally making good use of that ski mask to pay for her Parkinsons meds, which, Brennan notes, can cost as much as $10,000 a month. After a brief bout of feelings in his legsthanks to a solution Zack quietly cooked up by posing as a doctor onlineHodgins (TJ Thyne) acknowledged the sensation was temporary and he would have to stay in his chair. In this episode is a reference to Lethal Weapon 2, 3, and 4. (Previously, only Sweets knew that truth; that secret died with him.) It was also one ofBones' more ingenious narrative twists, though, as it brought to a head several of the show's more pressing plot lines. He and his wife married on 4 January 1992 and spent their honeymoon in room #79 at the . Cam confesses to Angela that it is nice to have him around. Acker said the truck was going 40 to 45 mph and at that speed, destroyed the buggy and killed the occupant. Bones ' Season 11 finale ended with a major cliffhanger and a shocking return. A crime drama show's main characters are sometimes only as good as their worst counterparts, and villains like the Ghost Killer and Jacob Broadsky acted as perfect counterbalances to Brennan and Booth. Angela is sick, presumably from the night before, but reveals to Brennan that shes pregnant. This is the same name of a money launderer, real estate agent, P.I., etc., who works with the protagonists of all four Lethal Weapon films: the detectives Martin Riggs and Roger Murtagh. Ray Porter is a lobbyist who appears in The Knight on the Grid. Booth was eventually exonerated and freed from jail. Does clearing cache make computer faster? So, naturally, everyone's biggest question was how someone as sweet-natured as Zach could get roped into something so grisly? Despite going over the evidence, Cam and Brennan ultimately throw it out as was later revealed. But if you're wondering what sort of gig Cartwright booked to take him permanently away from his Jeffersonian family, he landed a series co-lead in Syfy's tragically short-lived,X-Men styledsci-fi sagaAlphas. The Knight on the Grid about Zach - Bones - Fanpop. For all his psychological insights, the greatest gift Dr. Wyatt gives this investigation is a shot of fresh hope. The judge reveals that Archbishop Wallace and Dr. Sweets have offered their support in Russ' case, pinpointing Booth's involvement, and considering Russ' parole officer's advice to forgive Russ' violation, allows Russ to serve 30 days with electronic monitoring afterward, much to Julian's chagrin. What is more true to Zacks character and the kind of emotion of the show is to resolve it., RELATED: The Bones Cast, Producers Reflect on Starting the Final Season, The roller coaster Zack went on to arrive at this place was a vital one for the writers. Bones. When her husband tells her that the cars, and the names on those cars, could be a clue, Brennan snaps, Ill keep an eye out for a car named Killer Bank Robber Accomplice. Then they talk to a woman named Dawn (Jaime Bergman) whose car matches some of the parts of the accomplices car, and it doesnt wind up being especially germane to the case but here we are in Bones final four episodes and heres David Boreanazs wife in a gold spandex onesie because why on earth not. Brennan brings in the patellas, which bear stress markers indicating the victim spent a lot of time on his knees. Directed by But I was wondering if anybody else ever got annoyed that in season 4 the writers when Zach returned basically called him innocent and that he only told gormagon where to find the lobbyist. the Season 3 DVD set as a bonus), nothing is mentioned about the. Before the events in The Conspiracy in the Corpse, Sweets and Daisy were married and their restored relationship resulted in her pregnancy with their son; Seeley Lance. His body was eventually located in "The Steal in the Wheels" and used to exonerate Zack for the murder of Mr. Porter. Even "less than lethal" weapons can kill though. Lobbying is important for a . Yeah, we were a bit surprised, too. Porter's remains and murder scene are re-examined by Jack Hodgins in The Flaw in the Saw, and he comes across evidence on his rib that could potentially exonerate Zack. Though Zack worried he may unknowingly have been responsible for the Puppeteer murdersand Brennan (Emily Deschanel) agreed with him that the evidence was conclusive he was guiltyBooths (David Boreanaz) gut told him there was more to the story. Yea, I get that. The group has already spent more than $22 million on lobbying on drug pricing and other issues this year, while the pharmaceutical industry as a whole has spent an unprecedented $171 million on . At least 39 people have been killed by police Tasers in 2015 so far, according to The Guardian. [2] However, only the name has any relevance on the show, as Hodgins borrows it to refer to the killer for his dual reverence for and apparent dislike of secret societies and fraternal orders, including the Knights of Columbus. So, it was a big thing to do at the end of Season 11., But while the intention was always to clear the air about Zacks real involvement with Gormogon, the writers didnt immediately dismiss making him a part of this serial killer arc. In the final season, writers retconned Zach's murder of Ray Porter, revealing that Gormogon's previous apprentice actually killed The Lobbyist. Shes pored over the rest of the evidence but cant find anything new, and even Hodgins doesnt think theyve got a chance of finding the apprentices body after almost 10 years. How do you know if you have fatal insomnia? I remember getting that script in my trailer and making an audible like, 'What? Sweets hypothesizes that the stolen kneecaps probably have some sort of significance to the killer. Fans of the series will hardly argue Cartwright's talents, or his unique ability to make Vincent Nigel-Murray feel so authentic. The Gormogons were an anti-Masonic order of the 18th century. But mainly how like Im pretty sure the writers had him as an actual murderer until he told sweets that. In The Steal in the Wheels, after all attempts to find evidence at the murder scene pointing to Zack's innocence fail, Hodgins searches for the body of the Apprentice, Porter's real killer to prove he killed Porter and not Zack. Zacks story is that the previous apprentice is actually the one who killed the lobbyist Zack confessed to killing; that same night, Gormogon killed that apprentice so Zack could take his place. The industry increased its lobbying spending by 6.3 percent in the first quarter. Indeed, the victim is soon identified by dental records as Father Douglas Cooper, Vicar General to the Archbishop of D.C., Father Stephen Wallace. Lobbyist is not a very old word, less than 200 years old, yet in that time it has already managed to create confusion and false impressions. I love it here." Big Tech lobbyists are among the biggest spenders in Washington. Who killed the lobbyist in Bones season 12? Gormogon case still being open. In season three, a shocking twist revealed Addy was working with the seasons big bad The Gormogon, and even killed someone for him, the lobbyist Ray Porter, confessing his crime to the team. He makes his first on-screen appearance in "The Knight on the Grid" (episode 8), although his former master, Arthur Graves, appears earlier in that episode, and his late apprentice, Jason Harkness (Andrew James Allen), appeared in the season premiere. The Knight on the Grid Copyright 2023 Meredith Corporation. yea, Zack killed the lobby guy, in extended version of the episode he confesses to the murder, but they give him psych care because he helped them get the master. Ultimately, in light of this new evidence, Zack's conviction in the murder of Ray Porter is reversed and his life sentence overturned. Not all the victims have yet been identified, but at least one bone in each sculpture was added for its significance to its owner. Yea I never really doubted it honestly. We knew [his exit] would happen before the end of this season, so the story [had] been in the works for a while. The bones of Black children who died in 1985 after their home was bombed by Philadelphia police in a confrontation with the Black liberation group which was raising them are being used as a . Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I mean they were a season apart. On Wednesday morning, tech sector lobbyists thought they were in the . You could say that Booth was in a round about way responsible for Max's death, but under the circumstances, it . Angela and Hodgins rekindle their love after spending some quality time together in a jail cell, and decide to get married. Although he was supposed to have left on a short sabbatical, his character did not return to the show. EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Limited Or Anthology Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actor In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie. Judge Watkins calls Booth into his chambers to discuss Russ. He corresponds to the Corruptor tarot card on the Gormogon's schematic. So Gordon Gordon digs into a giant bucket of fried chicken while contemplating cannibalism (hes pulling a Scully! 18K subscribers in the Bones community. Cause if ya look at the end of season 3 ep 8 you can see its actually Zach holding the knife about to kill him. Sweets wanted him to tell his friends the truth, but Zack was afraid that since he is still an accessory to murder, if his secret were to come out that Booth would throw him in prison and Hodgins assured him that he would not do well in prison. If they can find the body of that apprentice, they might be able to prove Zack didn't kill the lobbyist. But before you go off in a rage at Hanson's blunt assessment of arguably one ofthe series' most brutal plot twists, you should know that hammering a nail through the heart of fans was not the only factor behind the decision. Back at Booth and Brennans house, Gordon Gordon cooks dinner while the couple celebrate that Zack might be coming home. At Gordon Gordons suggestion, Aubrey lets the idiot go and waits for Ray to lead them right to accomplice No. instead of the extended. Hodgins' and Sweets' understanding of typical practices among orders, such as the master-apprentice relationship, ritualistic meals, and sacred geometry inform the ongoing investigation of the murders. So that was really sad.". Gordon Gordon was right; she needed this. Heres hoping. When we did the cliffhanger at the end [of the season], I kind of knew where we were going, Peterson says. Also, Michaelas onscreen husband, T.J. Thyne, doubled as her real-life boyfriend for five years before they split. Zack confessed to Booth and Brennan that he never killed Ray Porter. Pam Grier reflects on her most iconic roles, from Coffy to Jackie Brown. In sympathy, Booth allows Russ to visit Amy and Haley in the hospital before taking him to jail. Dr. Gordon Gordon Wyatt is back to prescribe a little undercover work. The vault also yields a tapestry whose pattern corresponds to specific locations in Washington, D.C. and to tarot cards showing different archetypes, such as the Musician, the Bishop, and the Corruptor. You already know where this is heading. They use his symbolic association with everything backwards and upside-down to interpret a sequence of numbers on the fabric mailed to Brennan (it reads "Civitas Capitolium," meaning "Capital City"), and a map of Washington, D.C. with markers where the Gormogon's victims were found and where the vault was located. It was a victimless crime, Charlene cries. 130. Seth Rich's Death: Why a GOP Lobbyist Will Pay $100,000 To Learn Who Killed the DNC Staffer. Noah Hawley Brennan sends Amy to a doctor named Leo Getz. 2. Gavin Nichols, a violinist. You might be right. 1. Rays giant face bruise gives him away, so Aubrey (with the help of the corn dog) provokes him into an attack and brings him into custody. I havent had this much excitement since my last Baked Alaska fiasco.. He advises Booth and Brennan to use the older sculpture against Gormogon, and explains that he sent Brennan the kneecaps in the hope that she might install them in his sculpture. Unnamed (former apprentice; deceased), The Gormogon was introduced as a cannibalistic serial killer in the third-season premiere, "The Widow's Son in the Windshield", and has made appearances in the form of teeth marks on bones examined by the Jeffersonian scientists. The squints at the Jeffersonian were able to put the final pieces together: the killer was Zacks doctor, Dr. Roshan (Ravi Kapoor). Entertainment Weekly may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Truth be told, it seems like only yesterday we were watching the beloved supporting character bleed out on the floor of the Jeffersonian lab whilebegging of the cosmos, "Please don't make me leave. I think on a show like that, you're trying to do a lot of things. The shows creator, Hart Hanson, stated that Saroyans role was a better fit with the rest of the characters in the series. I agree that it looks like Zach, but could have not been him too. "Oh my God. Booth has been demoted to desk duty while Cam and her team are still reeling from Brennans absence. Protect People, Not Police Lobbyists. On Bones, Angela and Temperance Brennan are best friends, as the two are in real life. If you don't want to know what happened at the end, stop . So unlike Hannibal Lecter, Addy turned out to be completely innocent of the murder, having only helped find the lobbyist, who was actually killed by The Gormogons former apprentice. Mark Wilson/Getty Images. In a candid interview with TV Line,Bones creator Hart Hanson now freely admits that the character's "fan favorite" status was a key reason Vincent Nigel-Murray was marked for death on the series. Gilbert Murray, a timber industry lobbyist, was killed in Sacramento. Just so heartbreaking. Sweets was ultimately killed in the season 10 premiere; Bones executive producer Stephen Nathan said Sweets was killed because Daley wanted time off to direct a movie, and he was concerned that Daleys absence would be too long, especially if the directing job led to other jobs. Booth wants double G to read over the transcripts of Sweets sessions with Zack in the hopes hell find something the rest of them missed. The object turns out to be a human tooth, which Zack matches to the marks left in the bones in the sculpture. In The Day in the Life, Zack has his appeal where Hodgins testifies that the blood found on the Apprentice's body was an exact match to that of Ray Porter, proving that the Apprentice was the killer. He then burned her body. He was cannibalized, and his remains were sent to the Jeffersonian in The Pain in the Heart spread across various multiple containers with bones from Limbo. But of course, it was really sad. Hes literally wearing a T-shirt with a car on it that says, Were back. Did he just make it?? Zack Addy: murderer - Bones. Brennan agreed to re-examine the evidence and Booth agreed to help him get released from the institution. Ever since his death, he was only referred to, by the main characters, as The Lobbyist. How Michaela Conlin Reacted To The Big Zack Addy Plot Twist On Bones - Exclusive. It seemed like the right thing to do; its respectful for people who are dealing with actual [disabilities]. Right. And so I feel like you can't try to please everybody because you'll never win. He confessed because he assumed that he would kill if The Master asked him to, but after having a chance to kill The Puppeteer and ultimately refusing to finish the job, he learned that he is not capable of killing, not even to save himself. I didn't buy into the reformation of the story myself. He also determines that teeth recovered from the accident scene were pulled from a mouth using pliers. Subreddit dedicated to discussion of the Fox TV show Bones. https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/bones/images/d/d6/Gormogon_Apprentice.png/revision/latest?cb=20170620221635. It probably doesnt involve escaping the pit. The family lived in Studio City. Zack Addy (former apprentice) They assumed he was holding out on them. Wendell, the security guy, tells Booth out back he taped the door lock around 3 a.m. but the tape's gone. CNN . Miller lived across a large field from the accident scene, Acker said. Zack told them that if they smelled meat cooking, it would mean the Gormogon had claimed another victim. The final episode of Conlin's Apple TV+ series "For All Mankind" airs today. They take Ned into interrogation, and Brennan takes off her wig but leaves the rest of her undercover outfit just as it is because she likes to look like an edgy 90s mall kid while she catches killers. After examining the body in the lab, Zack determines that the kneecaps were surgically removed, and Cam and Hodgins decide the victim has been dead for three days. Ever since his death, he was only referred to, by the main characters, as The Lobbyist. Zack did not kill the lobbyist. Later in season 8, Hodgins loses his money due to the machinations of killer and hacker Christopher Pelant, who hacks Hodgins accounts while using the same computer system to target a military drone at a school in Afghanistan, forcing Hodgins to sacrifice his money by allowing the computer to keep running so that the . . Realizing that Sweets might be right, Brennan installs the kneecaps and prepares to transport the sculpture, hoping the Gormogon will attempt to intercept it. Upon interviewing Wallace, Booth and Brennan discover that Father Cooper had been on sabbatical writing a book about early Christianity. The boy, who has not been . did NOT look like Zack, completely wrong face. the elements of style by strunk and white. "So I do remember just being genuinely very surprised. (Im still not sure I understand why Max had to die, but its good to see he hasnt been forgotten.) 1. When Booth and SWAT stormed the Gormogon's home, he was seen eating a piece of meat, which was most likely human. David Gelernter, a computer science professor at Yale, lost the use of his right hand, suffered severe burns and shrapnel . Here are 5 ways lobbyists are corrupting our government. Ned Dixon, otherwise known as the third accomplice, tries to get out of there, but Brennan is hot on his tail (Stop hitting me! After the big reveal, Dr. Camille Saroyan (Tamara Taylor) sums up the fandom's pure shock with the bewildered announcement, "I did not see that coming.". Why did Bones get cancelled? We knew that one of our squints, who are [played by] very, very talented actors, would get a job. That killer waiting in the closet. Warning: This post contains major spoilers for the Bones season premiere. However, it gave Conlin closure before she said goodbye to her character, and the Jeffersonian, for good. I know some people have complained about like the arc for Zach but honestly I have no probables with it, I wish they would have just committed to it tho, ya know. During the first several seasons, we saw Dr. Temperance Bones Brennan as a fit woman, but by the end of the last season, shed gained weight. Fans can catch up on "Bones" on Hulu, while Conlin's new film, "Bad Trip,"is available on Netflix. Recent episode discussion, links to new trailers Zack's story is that the previous apprentice is actually the one who killed the lobbyist Zack confessed to killing; that same night, Gormogon killed that apprentice so Zack could take his place. Scientists are now analyzing the human remains to try to learn more about . And while star Emily Deschanel and her alter ego Temperance Brennan were pregnant during the first half of the season, the only episode taped after the September birth of Deschanels son Henry was the fictional babys arrival. "Okay. They realize that Barabbas, a rapist who appears in the New Testament, features on the seal and a tapestry in the vault. Cam even threw away his latest findings because they seemed so convenient that she thought he might just be making them up, which would be insulting if not for the fact that you know every single person on this team would love to do the same. I haven't found many people in fanbase who were not surprised that Zack became a Judas. Im not really questioning if like in the shows lore wether he did it or not. I think he did have to go through a journey to come out the other side safer and a better human beingAnd by the end of Season 12, we realize that Zack is in a better place that will give comfort to a lot of fans., The conclusion of the Puppeteer arc also marks an important end for Bones: Roshan was the shows final serial killer. Before the season finale "The Pain in the Heart", reviewers and fans speculated that the audience has actually already met him, perhaps being psychologist Dr. Lance Sweets.[1]. Zack could be back! Booth cheers. So yes. Is this setting up for something? Michaela shared some similarities with her character, Angela. A man at the . Russ blames his sister for betraying him, and Brennan goes to the prison to confront her father, who admits he told Russ that Booth wouldn't arrest him if he came to D.C. Bribery is an effort to buy power, while lobbying is just an effort to influence it; but admittedly, the distinction between the two can be . I felt satisfied with it," she said. Mr. Porter doesn't believe Booth and Brennan when they warn him about his safety, telling them he thinks it's a scare tactic related to some other business he has with the F.B.I. But I would not label him as a serial killer., RELATED: Bones TJ Thyne on Hodgins Life-Changing Twist. Fans had mixed feelings on the follow-up to the plot twist, which had happened almost a decade prior. I liked Zach but honestly it bothered me how much they messed with his story. The lobbyist's primary responsibility is to understand the policy initiatives of regional, federal, and . His kneecaps, essential in prayer, are added (by Brennan) to the silver skeleton, and he corresponds to the Bishop tarot card on the Gormogon's schematic. He gave The Master information about the lab, made a set of false teeth for him out of canines taken from the bone storage and also claims to have aided him in the murder of Ray Porter. Foxs Bones has formally decided to write star Emily Deschanels real-life pregnancy into the series storyline, TVLine has learned. The good doctor cozies up under a blanket with the files, tea and biscuits, a Union Jack pillow, and a fake portable fireplace because hes obviously stopped pretending that he wants to assimilate into this country and also because he lives his life right. It's long been known that bones consist largely of calcium. Until it turned out he was a KILLER Until it turned out he WASNT A KILLER. Will they be able to stop the Gormogon before he kills again? It is Amy Hollister, her brother Russ' girlfriend. The lobbying couple was found stabbed to death in their Loomis home Monday, March 28, 2022. One explanation that has often been proposed for its origin is that it comes from the Willard Hotel in Washington DC. But I also always found Zach supremely creepy and was relieved he turned out to be a homicidal maniac and left the show. As soon as they get to the derby, Brennan takes one look at Booths fake mullet and regrets everything which is bad for her but great for me because I love Sarcastic Brennan. Deschanel revealed in a 2019 interview that David Boreanaz was one reason why she has such fondness regarding her memories of filming.

Dynasty Financial Partners S 1, Tyongeee Relationship, Dell Poweredge R740 Visio Stencils, Tom Rennie Portland, Can A Creature With Summoning Sickness Crew A Vehicle, Articles W

No Comments

who killed the lobbyist in bones

Post A Comment